The Best Gifts for a Christmas Gift Exchange - That Everyone Will Want to Steal

We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more ›

It's time for the annual Christmas gift exchange! Whether it's a hilarious White Elephant with friends or a thoughtful Secret Santa at the office, the goal is to bring a gift that gets a great reaction. This guide is packed with the best gift exchange ideas—presents that are funny, clever, and so good that everyone will be fighting to steal them.

The Gift Exchange Golden Rules

To be a great gift exchange participant, follow these simple rules:

Know Your Audience: A quirky gift for friends might not be appropriate for a formal office party.
Stick to the Price Limit: Don't be the person who goes way over or under the agreed-upon budget.
Think "Broadly Appealing": The best gifts are often those that almost anyone would be happy to receive.

The Best Gifts for Any Christmas Exchange

Here are our top picks, from the genuinely useful to the hilariously weird.

For a "White Elephant" or "Gag Gift" Exchange

The goal here is laughter. These gifts are funny, quirky, and guaranteed to be the center of attention.

A Hilarious and Weird Board Game: Look for a party game that's a little bit strange and perfect for a group.
A Bacon-Scented Candle or Soap: A classic gag gift that is both bizarre and amusing.
A Custom Bobblehead: A hilarious gift if you're assigned a specific person in a Secret Santa.
A Funny Coffee Mug: A mug with a sarcastic or witty quote is a can't-fail funny gift. For more ideas, see our guide to the best gag gifts for Christmas.

For a "Secret Santa" or "Favorite Things" Exchange

These are the best Christmas gift exchange gifts when you want to give something genuinely useful and cool.

A High-Quality Insulated Coffee Tumbler: A YETI or Stanley tumbler is a premium, practical gift that anyone would love to get.
A Portable Power Bank: Everyone needs one, and it's a highly useful tech gift that's always appreciated.
A Cozy Throw Blanket: A super-soft fleece or sherpa blanket is the perfect gift for the cozy season.
A Gourmet Hot Sauce Set: A curated set of interesting hot sauces for the foodie in the group.

[note]Always check the specific rules of your gift exchange! Knowing how many times a gift can be "stolen" is a key part of the strategy.[/note]

For an Office Gift Exchange

When in doubt, keep it professional, useful, and appropriate for the workplace.

A Desk Plant: A small, low-maintenance succulent or snake plant in a nice pot.
A Set of High-Quality Pens: A genuinely useful gift for any office worker.
A Gift Card to a Local Coffee Shop: The safest and most-loved gift in any office.
A Box of Gourmet Chocolates: A shareable and sophisticated treat. For more ideas, see our guide on the best office Christmas gifts.

Conclusion

The key to winning the Christmas gift exchange is to bring a present that's a perfect blend of humor, thoughtfulness, and broad appeal. Whether you choose a hilarious gag gift or a surprisingly useful gadget, your contribution will make the party even more fun and memorable. For even more festive inspiration, explore our ultimate guide to the best gifts for Xmas.

Gifts are for making an impression, not just for the sake of it.
**GiftsPick - Meticulous, Kind, Objective.